Independent agency · Brooklyn, NY · Licensed in all 50 states · 718-921-2300
Insurance Depot Inc.
Workers' Comp & Disability

Workers' Comp, Disability and Paid Family Leave: What New York Employers Must Carry

Insurance Depot team·3 min read·Updated October 2026
The short version
  • Most New York employers must carry workers' comp, disability (DBL) and Paid Family Leave.
  • Premium is based on payroll by class code and adjusted by your experience mod.
  • Uninsured subcontractors can be added to your premium at audit.
  • Safety programs and return-to-work plans lower claims and long-term costs.

New York requires most employers to carry three separate employee benefit coverages. Getting them right protects your employees, keeps you compliant, and avoids penalties that can be severe. Managing them well can also save a meaningful amount on one of your largest insurance costs.

The three required coverages

CoverageWhat it paysCovers
Workers' compensationMedical care, lost wages, rehabilitation and death benefitsInjuries and illnesses on the job
Disability benefits (DBL)Partial wage replacementInjuries and illnesses off the job
Paid Family Leave (PFL)Partial wage replacement with job protectionBonding with a new child, caring for a seriously ill family member, military family needs

DBL and PFL are typically written together on one policy, and employers may collect a limited employee contribution toward their cost through payroll deductions, within the limits set by the state.

Who must be covered?

Nearly all for-profit employers with one or more employees in New York, full- or part-time, must carry workers' comp. That includes many family members working in the business. Certain sole proprietors, partners and corporate officers may be excluded under specific rules. Because the rules are technical, and the penalties for being uninsured are steep, it's worth confirming your situation with us.

Important for contractors

If you hire subcontractors who don't carry their own workers' comp, New York law can treat their workers as your employees for comp purposes. Always collect a valid certificate (form C-105.2 or U-26.3 for NYSIF) before work begins.

Metal fabrication workshop with workers in safety glasses
Workers' comp premiums are calculated by job classification. Correctly classifying shop, field and office payroll matters.

How your premium is calculated

Workers' comp premium starts with a simple formula: payroll ÷ 100 × class rate × experience mod, followed by any schedule credits, discounts and state assessments.

  • Class codes: Every job is assigned a classification. A roofer, an electrician, a warehouse worker and a clerical employee each have very different rates.
  • Payroll: Estimated at the start of the policy and audited after it ends.
  • Experience modification rate (EMR): Compares your actual claims with those expected for businesses your size and type. A 0.85 mod means a 15% credit; a 1.25 mod means a 25% surcharge.

Surviving the year-end audit

After each policy year, the carrier audits your payroll and recalculates the final premium. The most common audit surprises are:

  1. Payroll that grew more than estimated during the year
  2. Employees reclassified into higher-rated codes
  3. Payments to subcontractors with no proof of coverage
  4. Overtime not properly separated (in NY, the overtime premium portion is generally excluded from comp payroll when properly documented)

Keep clean payroll records by class, keep subcontractor certificates on file, and tell us about business changes during the year. Pay-as-you-go billing, where premium is calculated from each payroll run, can eliminate most audit surprises.

What to do when an employee is hurt

  1. Get medical care for the employee immediately.
  2. Report the injury to your carrier promptly. In New York, employers must report within 10 days of learning of an injury that causes lost time beyond the day of injury or needs more than first aid.
  3. Document what happened, including witnesses and photos.
  4. Stay in touch with the employee and plan modified duty when the doctor allows.

Return-to-work programs are one of the most effective cost controls available. Employees who return to modified duty recover faster, and shorter lost-time claims weigh less on your experience mod.

How to lower workers' comp costs

  • Review class codes with your agent every year
  • Join New York's Certified Safety Program or Drug and Alcohol-Free Workplace Program where eligible. Both can earn premium credits.
  • Train supervisors to spot and correct hazards
  • Report every claim quickly, since late reporting increases claim costs
  • Shop the market: carriers' appetites differ widely by industry

Where coverage comes from

Workers' comp in New York is written by private carriers and by the New York State Insurance Fund (NYSIF). For higher-hazard classes such as roofing, demolition and steel erection, or for businesses with past claims, NYSIF and specialty carriers are often the right fit. We compare all available options so you get the best combination of price, payment terms and claims service.

General information only, not legal advice or a coverage determination. Coverage depends on your policy wording. Talk to your agent, and where appropriate your attorney, about your situation.

Get a quote in under a minute

Tell us what you need. A licensed agent compares carriers and calls you back.

CallGet a Quote